It's fair to say that I wasn't a huge fan of Josh Radnor's first film as a writer/director "Happythankyoumoreplease." While the movie had promise and some strong points, it veered a little too far into preciousness and quirk for my taste. I might have been in the minority, though, as the film scored an Audience Award at Sundance. But for me, many of its plot digressions seemed a little too contrived to be taken seriously. In his second effort, "Liberal Arts," I find myself having a similar reaction. Overall, though, the movie works much more cohesively. It strikes some irresistibly bittersweet moments and features some winning performances. But every time Radnor scores with a heartfelt, affectionate, or funny scene, he counters with something too convenient or unbelievable to follow it up. Simply put, "Liberal Arts" is a good movie (sometimes very good) that struggles to find a consistent tone. Radnor has talent as both a writer and director, sometimes he just needs to rein in the artificiality that comes with excessive quirk.
"Liberal Arts" relies on a middle-aged nostalgia for one's college days. As a central theme, it is one that strikes a real emotional chord and is something that many of us can easily identify with. Radnor plays a New York City resident who is invited to his small town alma mater to honor a favorite professor (Richard Jenkins). The two men share an easy bond and their scenes together have a quiet poignancy and effectiveness. While there, Radnor becomes entangled with a feisty co-ed (Elizabeth Olsen) despite their sixteen year age difference. There are some fresh comic moments throughout. I especially liked an uncredited Zac Effron as an ethereal life force that connects rather fancifully with Radnor. But there are also moments of deep sadness. Jenkins struggles with his life choices and Radnor has to face the realities of his relationship with the younger Olsen. What does it mean to finally grow up? That's the position Radnor finds himself confronting.
The movie has some terrific highlights. Jenkins is great. Allison Janney has an amusing, but brief, side plot. But for me, the movie all but belongs to Olsen. She's so likable and, more importantly, so believable. It's hard to imagine not falling in love with her. Breezy and heartfelt in equal measures, she epitomizes every idealistic crush you might have experienced. When she's on screen the movie soars. I might have lived without a couple of peripheral stories like Radnor inexplicably befriending a troubled student. This is one of the developments that seems far more scripted than real. Still, "Liberal Arts" has its heart in the right place. It strikes an appropriately wistful tone and should be an appealing diversion to most. While I wanted to love it (and I did love the central plot of the film), I merely liked it due to some of the extraneous choices. About 3 1/2 stars for me, I'll round up for Olsen who is becoming an increasingly impressive young actress. KGHarris, 12/12.
With so many heartbreaking films in the cinema today, it is refreshing to encounter and engage with Josh Radnor's Liberal Arts, a heart mending film. A film that dares to say that things aren't that bad, in a time when cynicism runs rampant through the streets. And I don't know about you, but I could use a healthy dose of optimism in the movies I watch. Josh Radnor grabs cynicism by the shoulder and gently leads him out of the movie theater, while calmly embracing compassion, awareness, and unabashed optimism. Josh Radnor may just be the soul that saves all of our weary souls. Josh's innate ability to create and inspire is one of the most over-looked talents today. How is this guy not on the front page of the newspaper every day? If you haven't seen Liberal Arts, then you need to get on that. It is by no means a run of the mill romantic comedy with cliched dialogue and unrealistic dramatic debacles. It is a beautiful symphony of impeccable directorial finesse, precise subtle nuanced acting, and a wonderfully aware script with resonant quotes that stay with you long after you leave the theatre.
Josh's clear vision for Liberal Arts really paid off. The beautiful cadence with which each actor speaks is unmatched by any other movie(not that it's a competition, but it's totally a competition, and Liberal Arts wins, by a landslide, a very peaceful landslide that has no casualties, just bruised egos perhaps). With these unique, intriguing characters, it's no wonder there is never a dull moment in this movie. Jesse Fisher(Josh Radnor), is a 35-year old college admissions counselor, who is less than enthused about his career, and returns to his alma mater, Kenyon College, for one of his favorite professor's retirement dinners. While on campus, he becomes entranced by the spirited, effervescent Zibby(Elizabeth Olsen), a 19-year old student, and complications ensue. A pleasant surprise in the film is the affable, ethereal Nat(Zac Ephron), who extoles wisdom effortlessly and with grace, as if he is plugged in to some universal truth. The cast is rounded out with Richard Jenkins, Allison Janney, Elizabeth Reaser, and John Magaro, who each give stellar performances in their own right. Richard Jenkins is an absolute delight, bringing his trademark wonderful energy to the film. He plays Professor Peter Hoberg, who is struggling with his retirement from teaching. Allison Janney is at her best, playing a spit fire of a character as Jesse's former teacher. Elizabeth Reaser gives an endearing performance as a lovable bookworm who crosses Jesse's path. And last but definitely not least, John Magaro gives a moving performance as a student struggling to find his place in the collegiate world. With so many great characters, it is difficult not to relate to them all (note: unless you are emotionally devoid). A beautifully sad common thread that strings these characters together is their dissatisfaction with the way things are. Perhaps the real message behind Liberal Arts is that if you can stop struggling against life, and just go with the flow, you will be happier for it. You will realize that, "Everything is okay," as the ever-present Nat reminds us.
Liberal Arts is not only about love and the intricacies of relationships, it's a celebration of books and music, while also being a great mirror for some self-reflection. It deals with a multitude of subjects such as: morality, grace, rejection, self-esteem, divinity, ethics, and aging. With the jaded perspective of our society being that youth is good and aging in any way, shape, or form is bad, it is uniquely refreshing to hear that aging can be a lovely process that you get to take part in. Beyond just that, I believe that Radnor is also trying to reveal to his audience that any part of life can be enjoyed, even if, or perhaps, especially if, society has marked it as unenjoyable. It is all about your perspective, and how you perceive the event to unfold. In addition to being just blatantly brilliant, Liberal Arts has these delectable morsels of inspirational quotes sprinkled throughout the film. Here are just a few of my favorites: "Any place you don't leave is a prison", "Grace, I realized, is neither time nor place dependent; all we need is the right soundtrack", and "Fortune never smiles on those who say no". These lovely, luminous gems in this soul-satisfying movie carry with them an enduring resonance. Don't be surprised when you find yourself, days later, contemplating them in a reverie.
You can enjoy the ninety-seven minutes of Liberal Arts and then go back to your normal everyday life, or you can fully embrace the sage advice that lives within the movie, let it permeate your soul, and permanently improve the circumstances of your life. Simply allow your mind to ruminate on the heartfelt wisdom of the movie. Let the words and ideas roll around in your head and in your heart, like clothes in a dryer, until they are carefully arranged and neatly folded in your mind. Watching Liberal Arts is like eating a delicately planned out meal in a restaurant. You may not know how it was made, or what exactly is in it, but by the end, you leave with a delightful feeling in your gut, a happy smile on your face, and an overall pleasant feeling of satiety. Feeling like you are in on a life secret. While watching it, you get this feeling that you are basking in greatness; that there is something greater than yourself struggling to emerge. Like any great movie, you walk out of it not only with a huge grin on your face, but also believing that the characters really do exist somewhere out in the world. To me, there is no greater compliment to a writer than that.
It's as if somehow Josh Radnor found his way into your mind, extracted all the worthy treasures of your subconscious, then took everything that you have wanted to express and say to the world, and turned it into this wonderful, heartfelt movie. Pinpointing emotions you didn't know that you had. Extoling wisdom that you wish you had been able to put into words. Josh Radnor is daring to blaze a trail into uncharted territory in Hollywood, creating a genuinely uplifting film. Trying to break down the walls of cliched, predictable, explosion-driven movies, and attempting to build up the confidence of the audience. A rare trait for any filmmaker to exude these days. And he does it with such elegance and grace, finding a way straight into our hearts.
Buy Liberal Arts (2012) Now
Now THIS is one to watch for! It is witty, intelligent, well-acted, adult, textured and beautifully acted, with a gorgeous soundtrack. Our 2012 Seattle International Film Festival audience could scarcely contain ourselves as we exited the theater. We had watched decent people trying to cope with the vagaries of growing up, each at his or her own pace, each with his or her own degree of success.
Let's look at some of these nice people:
* Josh Radnor ("How I Met Your Mother") is Jesse, an Admissions officer for a New York City school, called to give a speech for a former professor who is retiring at his old alma mater. He is a bookworm who says a dual English/History degree should make a graduate fully unemployable. He meets a couple of undergrads while visiting his old campus.
* Elizabeth Olsen ("Martha Marcy May Marlene") is Zibby, a young woman wise for her years but who views a relationship with our hero as a possible short-cut to maturity. She gives him a mix-tape filled with works by dead white males, i.e., European composers Wagner, Beethoven, Mozart, Vivaldi and Shubert. That is his FIRST surprise from her! She is smart, decent and has great insight. And she LOVES "snail mail."
* John Magaro ("My Soul to Take") is Dean, the other student our hero meets on campus. This guy hates hyperbole and is terminally depressed! He keeps re-reading a book written by an author who killed himself. He's attending college because he got a "full ride" scholarship and his single mom is "soooo proud!"
* Richard Jenkins ("The Visitor") is Peter Hoberg, the professor trying to make the difficult transition to retirement.
* Allison Janney ("The Help") is Judith Fairfield, the acerbic professor who helped our hero learn to love dead white males (in this case the Romantic poets). She thinks he has a "gooey heart!"
* Elizabeth Reaser (the "Twilight" trilogy) is Ana, who works in a bookstore. She notices he reads dead white males, authors who shall remain nameless.
* Zac Efron ("The Lucky One") is Nat, who may or may not exist....
Writer/director Josh Radnor ("Happythankyoumoreplease") has a great future ahead. He doesn't talk down to his audience, his characters are literate, witty, decent and earnest. The soundtrack is absolutely wonderful and Radnor's bittersweet views on aging and age differences are very realistic. We laughed at his stunned reaction to a "Vampire" trilogy. This is top notch! Amazon.com will notify me when the DVD is available.
Read Best Reviews of Liberal Arts (2012) Here
I just watched this movie last night at a theater on the campus of Florida Atlantic University and it was one of the best movies I've seen all year. I mention that it was on a university campus because the staff, all undergraduates, thought the movies was terrific, so it isn't just the opinion of middle aged guys like me. Usually, if I see a movie in the theater, I don't get the DVD, but I will buy this one.
Unlike most American movies even indy's these days this is a movie that respects its screenwriter. As a result, in plot and dialogue, it is like many foreign movies: designed for serious minded people, grown-ups, which is appropriate for a movie about growing up (no matter how old you are) and the limits of intellect without character. It is hard for me to define the ideas of the movies without making it sound dull, but it is also extraordinarily funny. Even now, 24 hours after I saw the movie, lines of dialogue or certain scenes keep coming back to me, alternately making me laugh or ponder the wisdom of the film, from the hilariously unromantic date with an inspired professor of romantic literature to the trenchant observation that "guilt before you act is morality," this will be a movie I will want to watch many times.
Want Liberal Arts (2012) Discount?
This superbly acted and directed study of the ambiguity in all of its main characters deserves the highest praise. Any ending was possible even though several would not be liked by certain viewers. But the ending is not the point. Each character struggles with his or her inner demons to find a personal solution to life (or death). It is their individual vacillating approaches to a personal ending with its intellectual underpinnings which which makes this film so grand.
Martin P. Feldman
Several male comedians' have (in the movies) a character best described as their "alter-ego', ie: a character of the opposite sex engaged in an adventure of some sort or another.
